Category: Craft & Judgment

  • The draft is the cheap part

    The first draft used to be the hard part of the job. It’s free now, and almost nobody has rethought what to do with the hours that frees up.


    The cost moved

    An AI tool writes a competent first draft of almost anything in about the time it takes to describe what you want. Copy, a brief, a deck outline, a function, a plan. The making of the thing, the part that used to eat the afternoon, is close to free.

    So the job didn’t get easier. It moved. What’s left is the work that was always the harder half, and we just didn’t have to face it this often: deciding whether the thing is any good, and knowing what to do when it isn’t.

    Competent is the trap

    Here’s the uncomfortable part. AI output is rarely terrible. It’s confidently fine. It reads finished. It has the shape of good work: the right headings, a reasonable structure, sentences that sound like they mean something.

    Fine is the dangerous zone. Terrible you catch. Fine slips through, because noticing what’s generic, or quietly wrong, or off for your brand takes a trained eye and a second you’re tempted not to spend. The tool will hand you fine all day. It will never tell you that fine isn’t good enough here.

    Judgment is the scarce skill now

    What separates people now isn’t who can produce. Everyone can produce. It’s who can look at three competent drafts and know which one is right, which one is a trap, and which one to throw out and start over.

    That’s taste. It’s judgment. It’s knowing what good looks like in your context, for your audience, against a standard you carry in your head. None of that ships in the tool. You build it over years of doing the work, getting it wrong, and seeing why. It’s a lot of what an agency year installs and in-house quietly loses.

    You can’t license taste, you teach it

    Most organizations are about to make the same mistake with judgment that they made with every tool before it. Hand it out, expect quality to rise, and act surprised when the floor comes up but the ceiling doesn’t.

    The floor coming up is real, and it’s good. More people can make a passable thing. But the ceiling, the distance between passable and right, is decided by judgment. Judgment is the slowest thing to build and the one nobody puts in the budget. It’s the same story I keep coming back to: the tool is the easy part, the thinking is the hard part, and it’s a teaching problem, not a buying one.


    The free first draft is one of the better things to happen to this work in years. It just doesn’t do what people think it does. It doesn’t replace the judgment. It raises how much the judgment matters, because that’s now the only part that’s actually yours. The teams that come out ahead won’t be the ones generating the most. They’ll be the ones who can still tell the difference.



    I write about creative leadership, AI adoption, and the parts of the job nobody puts in a keynote. One post every two weeks.



  • What agencies taught me that in-house forgot

    Nobody in-house can be fired off the account. It sounds like safety. Mostly it’s how the standard slips.


    I spent one year inside Leo Burnett. I’ve spent nearly twenty since, in-house. So this is not a pitch for agency life — which was frequently miserable, occasionally cruel, and which I left on purpose.

    But a year in a good agency installs a few things in you by force. You don’t decide to learn them. The structure of the place makes them non-optional, and you either absorb them or you don’t last the year. Then you move in-house, where nothing enforces any of them, and you get to watch in slow motion which ones you actually kept.

    Fewer than you’d think. I’ve run in-house studios for two decades, and I’ve watched good teams — including ones I built myself — quietly lose things the agency beat into me. Not through laziness. Through the simple absence of anything making them hold on.

    Here’s what leaves first.

    The idea has to survive a room

    In an agency you present. Out loud, standing up, to people whose job is to find the weak seam in your thinking before the client does. You learn fast that a good idea and an idea that survives a room are two different objects, and that the second one is worth more.

    The presenting isn’t a tax on the work. It is the work. Defending an idea out loud is how you find out whether you believe it or just liked how it looked at two in the morning.

    In-house, that room disappears. Work arrives by proximity — a hallway aside, a Teams message, a file dropped in a folder — and it ships without anyone ever standing up to say why. Nobody pulls on the weak seam, because everybody’s polite and everybody’s staying for the holiday party. So the seam holds, right up until a stakeholder tugs it in a meeting, in front of people, and the work comes apart in a way it never would have at the agency.

    What you lose is the habit of defending the work before it needs defending. It’s the cheapest quality control there is, and in-house teams drop it the moment nothing forces them to keep it.

    What the comfort costs

    The rest of what goes is quieter, and it all traces to one source: in-house, there is no one who can take the account away.

    The standard is non-negotiable — until it’s “just internal.” The most expensive phrase in an in-house shop. It’s the sound of a bar being lowered. An agency ships the internal readout at the same standard as the client work, because a brand’s reputation doesn’t have an off-switch for audience. In-house, it’s just for us becomes a standing permit to be slightly worse — and slightly worse compounds.

    You start mistaking the stakeholder’s taste for the work’s quality. An agency client can reject the work but can’t touch your career. That distance is what lets you push back honestly. In-house, the person handing you the brief is a colleague who shapes your review — so you cave earlier and call it collaboration. Some of that is real partnership. A lot of it is fear wearing partnership’s clothes, and the work is what covers the difference.

    A monopoly supplier gets slow. An agency is always competing — against the shop down the street, the pitch it could lose, the creative one desk over. In-house creative has no competitor; it’s the only vendor its clients are allowed to use. Monopolies do not, as a rule, stay sharp. When nobody outside can beat you, the pressure that keeps you good has to be manufactured inside the building, on purpose, by someone — and usually nobody volunteers for that job.

    Precarious taught me things comfort can’t

    The engine under all of it is precarity. An agency can lose the account tomorrow, and everyone in the building knows it. It’s a brutal way to run a life, and it throws off a certain edge as a side effect — a refusal to coast, because coasting is visibly fatal.

    In-house removes the precarity, which is honestly one of the good things about it. Nineteen years in one organization is a gift I don’t take lightly. But the same stability that lets you build something lasting is what lets standards drift unpunished, because no external event ever arrives to make you pay for the drift. The account never leaves. Nothing forces the reckoning.

    I’m not arguing for churn. Fear is a terrible teacher — I’ve said that about AI adoption and it’s just as true here. The agency taught me these things through precarity, and precarity is a bad way to learn anything. It works, and it costs far too much.


    So the real thing an agency teaches isn’t any single discipline. It’s that the disciplines exist at all — and that in-house, they will not maintain themselves.

    Nobody is going to make your team present the work. Nobody is going to bounce the internal deck for being sloppy. No competitor is going to appear and force you to be good. The pressure an agency supplies for free, an in-house leader supplies by hand — every time, without the fear that once made it automatic.

    That’s the part nobody warns you about when you leave for the calmer job. The calm is real. So is the drift. Most of what I do now is the unglamorous business of manufacturing the pressure agencies get for nothing — holding the standard on purpose, because the account can’t leave, and something has to.


    I write about creative leadership, AI adoption, and the parts of the job nobody puts in a keynote. One post every two weeks.